Home » The Best Paint Colours » BENJAMIN & SHERWIN: Paint Colour Reviews » 9 BEST White Paint Colors, Sherwin Williams Designer Edition (Emerald)

9 BEST White Paint Colors, Sherwin Williams Designer Edition (Emerald)

Posted on April 6, 2021 by KylieMawdsley

White Snow, White Sand, Cotton, Cold Foam & more…

Sherwin Williams has some of the most popular white paint colours already, and their new Emerald Designer Edition definitely takes it up a notch.

Today, we’re taking a look at these new colours, focusing on those that could work well for your trim and cabinets, as well as those that might be better for ‘other purposes’.

All of that being said, these new whites come at a price (which we’ll get into below). And the price might be the ONLY THING holding these colours back from being the TOP white paint colours on the market because otherwise, they’re pretty friggin’ awesome.

Kitchen cabinets painted Sherwin High Reflective White, marble backsplash, white quartz, home decor on countertop. Pewter hardware. Kylie M Interiors Edesign, online paint colour consulting

When trying to find the best white paint colour for your project, there are a few things you must do BEFORE you start slappin’ paint on the walls…

1.  FIND THE WHITEST WHITE IN THAT BRAND

This is the white you’ll compare EVERY OTHER WHITE to. Here’s a list of each brand’s WHITEST whites.

2.  GRAB A FEW COMPARABLE WHITES

Find whites that are similar to the one you’re looking at. Four comparable whites are ideal.

Why?

Because the BEST way to pick a white paint colour is via comparison! Don’t read the label, or compare it to white paper or your pasty white legs (or is it just me that has these?). Instead, do the above and make your white paint pickin’ life a heck of a lot easier.

I also have OODLES of articles on how to pick the best white paint colour and I’ll link to them throughout. I’ll also include a full list at the end of this blog post, just because I love you.

Sherwin Williams Pure White in home office with leather chair. Best white paint color. Kylie M Interiors edesign, virtual or online paint color expert, diy decorating ideas and home staging

Sherwin Williams Pure White / Western Exposures Photography

TWO IMPORTANT THINGS before we get started…

1. THESE WHITES ARE ONLY AVAILABLE IN THE EMERALD DESIGNER LINE

The fact that you can ONLY get these whites in the Emerald line is one of the things that sets them apart from the other whites. HOWEVER, this isn’t bad, and I’ll tell you why.

Sherwin Williams new Emerald line is HIGH-QUALITY paint. And while the price reflects that; high-quality paint usually = high-end results*, high-quality paint often GOES further (as much as 50+ sq ft more coverage), and HIDES better (covers your old colour). This could save you from needing 2-3 additional coats or EVEN having to buy an extra gallon of paint. Keep this in mind if you feel a little sticker shock.  I understand that if you’re doing a large project or are on a budget, the price could be a turn-off, and I think it’s the ONE thing that will stop these colours from being the head honchos of the white world – these whites aren’t accessible to everyone wanting to paint.

But why do these new whites go further and cover better?

GOOD QUESTION! Every paint colour starts with a base, which is what’s in the can when you first take it off the shelf. The BASE of these new whites is whiter and purer. So, whereas you get blue with Extra White and not enough hide with the EVER contentious High Reflective White, these whites have it goin’ on from the get-go.

*I haven’t tried this paint yet. I don’t get paid for any of the paint colour reviews on my site – no financial contribution, free product samples, or even a virtual high-five or complimentary case of wine. Therefore, what I offer is my honesty, knowledge of colours, hands-on experience and research.

2. PHOTOS…or lack thereof

Because these are NEW colours and my E-Design clients haven’t had a chance to use them/send ‘after’ photos, I don’t have images. However, I do have the information and insights you’ve been LOOKING forI’ll also refer to other popular Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore white paint colours to give you some great points of reference.

Alabaster, White kitchen, Alabaster, Island Sherwin Iron Ore, Viatera Aria, Sandbar. Kylie M Interiors Edesign, online virtual paint color consulting. Kitchen remodel

Sherwin Williams Alabaster

BTW, I’m putting these whites in order of flexibility and my level of excitement at their arrival on the paint scene!

Sherwin Williams Designer Emerald Edition best white paint colours. Kylie M Interiors Edesign, diy design blogger, online advice

1. Review of Sherwin Williams White Snow SW 9541

LRV: White Snow has an LRV of 90. Not a true white, but definitely getting up there.

TYPE OF WHITE: White Snow isn’t obviously warm or cold, and in the words of the Late Great Goldilocks, it’s juuuuust right. Okay, so maybe it caters to a very minor warmth, but it’s negligible – and that’s an overstatement.

UNDERTONES: N/A. This doesn’t mean there aren’t any, it means they’re so subtly warm that the specifics aren’t worth paying attention to.

WHAT PAINT COLOURS WILL LOOK GOOD WITH WHITE SNOW?

I believe the question should be ‘what paint colours WON’T look good with White Snow!’ With no allegiance to being warm or cool, White Snow is super flexible and can accommodate warm or cool paint colours and MAYBE even some other whites.

The only areas I wouldn’t naturally gravitate towards White Snow are the following:

  • Warm neutrals. Warm neutrals such as beige, tan and cream, won’t look bad with White Snow – not at all! However, soft, warm whites will create a softer, more organic connection.
  • Warm earth-tones. Again, warm earth tones won’t look bad AT ALL with White Snow. However, with earth tones being ‘dirty’ colours, I’m more likely to choose soft whites when working with them.

WHAT BENJAMIN MOORE OR SHERWIN WILLIAMS COLOUR IS SIMILAR TO WHITE SNOW?

Again, comparison is key, especially if you’re new to paint colours!

Sherwin Williams High Reflective White is along similar lines and comes across WHITER looking when compared to White Snow. It also helps show off the VERY slight warmth in White Snow…

SHERWIN WILLIAMS HIGH REFLECTIVE WHITE

Hexagon marble tile on wall behind vanity, quartz countertop, High Reflective White cabinets. Kylie M INteriors Edesign, online paint color consultant

White paint colours with marble backsplash and countertop. Kylie M Interiors Edesign, online paint colour consulting and advice blogger

SUMMARY OF SHERWIN WILLIAMS WHITE SNOW

I’m in love with this colour, and if it weren’t for the price, I’d be doing it in our upcoming lake build. I DO think it’s going to be a popular choice for trims, cabinets, walls and exteriors, maybe even taking over from Sherwin Williams High Reflective White (which has SW employees worldwide cheering for joy…long story).

In fact, if we can all swallow the price tag, I think White Snow could be the next big white.

Do Your Cabinets, Trim & Walls Need to be the SAME WHITE????

2. Review of Sherwin Williams Cold Foam SW 9504

I haven’t been this excited about white since I popped open my last bottle of Riesling (which means I was excited this morning last night).

LRV: Cold Foam has an LRV of 84, making it a soft white – not true or bright.

TYPE OF WHITE: Cold Foam is a warm white, but it’s a PASSIVE warmth.

UNDERTONES: Here’s the reason I love Cold Foam so much – it has no noticeable undertone, while still having a subtle warmth. This means it isn’t committing to an undertone, which is GREAT. This reduced commitment means it’s going to be more flexible than a white with say, committed yellow undertones, which could be more reactive with some colours.

WHAT PAINT COLOURS WILL LOOK GOOD WITH COLD FOAM?

I don’t see red flags with ANY colours, other than those with higher chromas (intensities), meaning they’re more colourful than the earth-toned family. Other than that, fill yer boots!

WHAT BENJAMIN MOORE OR SHERWIN WILLIAMS COLOUR IS SIMILAR TO COLD FOAM?

Cold Foam is like an improved Greek Villa. If you love Greek Villa I’m not trying to cause a throw-down, I’m just saying it’s EVEN NICER than it. It has more warmth than Sherwin Williams Pure White and is VERY COMPARABLE to Sherwin Williams Alabaster.

Kitchen, white subway tile, Sherwin Alabaster cabinets, Viatera Aria quartz, subway tile. Sandbar. Kylie M Interiors Edesign, online decor advice

In the above photo, you’re looking at Sherwin Williams Alabaster. Cold Foam is certainly along similar lines.

SUMMARY OF COLD FOAM

Cold Foam has some GREAT things going for it, in particular, its MUTED warmth. I think that if its LRV were approx. three points higher, it would be PERFECT and would take over from Sherwin Williams Pure White as my GO-TO white paint colour.

3. Review of Sherwin Williams Cheviot SW 9503

I’m DAMN excited about Cheviot. Cheviot is Sherwin Williams newest warm white paint colour and I can’t WAIT until one of my Online Paint Colour Consulting clients tries it out!

LRV: With an LRV of 89, Cheviot fills a gap in Sherwin William’s white paint colour family, which was lacking a good white with this LRV (the next best ones are 86 and 93). This higher LRV puts Cheviot CLOSER to the bright end of things, but not quite at the ‘true white’ range.

TYPE OF WHITE: Cheviot is a WARM white. Whereas Sherwin Williams Alabaster is a popular SOFT warm white, Cheviot has a HIGHER LRV, giving us a whiter look without losing the warmth some homes need.

Read more: The FIVE Types of White Paint Colours

UNDERTONES: Being a warm white, it needs either yellow, orange or red undertones. Cheviot has a yellow undertone with a gorgeous bit of neutral to calm it down, making it look deliciously subtle and creamy. While its yellow/cream undertone is a bit more obvious than the previous two colours, it’s still quite soft.

WHAT PAINT COLOURS WILL LOOK GOOD WITH CHEVIOT?

Cheviot is VERY flexible while being slightly partial to warm colours. Cheviot also works with cool colours, with the understanding that the warm undertone of Cheviot will interact with cool colours and they’ll bounce off each other a bit. This can be a very pretty combo, making Cheviot look that WINK more yellow and the cool colour that bit stronger in comparison.

WHAT BENJAMIN MOORE OR SHERWIN WILLIAMS COLOUR IS SIMILAR TO CHEVIOT?

Interestingly enough, there isn’t another Sherwin Williams or Benjamin Moore white that’s really even CLOSE. Cheviot is WHITER and WARMER than Pure White (shown below), and considerably softer/less true than High Reflective White. Again, it picks up a bit of what Alabaster throws down, but lighter and a touch cleaner.

SHERWIN WILLIAMS PURE WHITE

Laundry room mudroom with Formica laminate countertop Carrara Bianco, marble look. Pure White walls and cabinets. Kylie M Interiors Edesign, online paint colour blogger

SUMMARY OF SHERWIN WILLIAMS CHEVIOT

With its brighter warmth, I think Cheviot will have reasonable popularity whether you’re using warm or cool paint colours. This high LRV really sets it apart from the more muted warmth of Sherwin Williams Alabaster and Benjamin Moore Cloud White.

4. Review of Sherwin Williams Cotton SW 9581

Cotton’s like the love-child between Sherwin Williams Pure White (which is my all-time fave white) and Sherwin Williams Alabaster. Not too warm, definitely not cold, and a GREAT LRV for a home that can’t pull off a true or bright white. Let’s check it out!

LRV: Cotton has an LRV of 83, making it a lovely soft white.

TYPE OF WHITE: Cotton is a WARM white.

UNDERTONES: Cotton has a very muted cream undertone (toned-down yellow).

WHAT PAINT COLOURS WILL LOOK GOOD WITH COTTON?

When it comes to Cotton, while it has some colour preferences and can shrink in the wash, it’s MORE about its flexibility with PRODUCTS. Many homes (kitchens in particular) can’t handle true or bright whites due to their existing finishes. Cotton is a colour that can bridge the gap between rooms that can’t handle a TRUE white, and homeowners who don’t want a white that’s too creamy/yellow.

As for colour preferences in particular…

  • Cotton loves warm colours that are muted and toned-down, nothing too rich, saturated or with a pink hue.
  • Cotton loves MANY earth-tones, as long as they aren’t too cool or too colourful.
  • Cotton even does okay with some of the stormier, muted grays, such as Sherwin Williams Silverplate and Tinsmith.

WHAT BENJAMIN MOORE OR SHERWIN WILLIAMS COLOUR IS SIMILAR TO COTTON?

When you compare whites, it’s easier to see the shift between temperatures, undertones and depths. This is why you should take a peek at Sherwin Williams Alabaster to see how it compares to Cotton. I’d also hit up Sherwin Williams Cold Foam and Greek Villa.

SHERWIN WILLIAMS ALABASTER

Sherwin Williams Alabaster best warm white paint colour. Client waiting room. Beach coastal colour. Client photo. Kylie M INteriors Edesign, online paint color consulting

My client’s waiting room

SUMMARY OF SHERWIN WILLIAMS COTTON 

Cotton should be reasonably popular, up there with Sherwin Williams Greek Villa and Alabaster. Comparing the three (and they are sooooo similar) Cotton comes across just a TOUCH more grounded, which suits me as it relates to Greek Villa, as its undertones always make me nervous.

5. Review of Sherwin Williams White Sand and Natural White (SW 9582 & SW 9542)

White Sand and Natural White are intriguing and QUITE similar to each other, so it’s a two-for-one this time!

LRV: The LRV of White Sand is 84. The LRV of Natural White is 83. This makes them both SOFT whites, not bright or true whites.

TYPE OF WHITE: Natural White has a muted, toned-down approach to the cool end of things. White Sand is muted, but might have a curious wink of warmth hiding in it (think ‘warm gray’, not cream).

UNDERTONES: Both Natural White and White Sand have AMAZING gray undertones which have been desperately needed in the soft white world.

Natural White is like a slightly less blue, more gray-violet tweak of Extra White. White Sand, on the other hand, is more muted, less cool with no COMMITTED cool undertone. In fact, it might seem just slightly warm in comparison. Lack of committed undertone can be a good thing, but remember, having such HIGH LRV’s, white paint colours are the most reflective and will pick up colours from their environment.

WHAT PAINT COLOURS WILL LOOK GOOD WITH WHITE SAND & NATURAL WHITE?

White Sand and Natural White will be much fussier than the previous whites…

White Sand

  • White Sand doesn’t love fresh cool colours, as they’re too clean for its more muted approach. At most, it likes an earth-toned blue or violet and preferably no green.
  • White Sand’s favourite colour partners are cool grays, the stormier the better!
  • I can’t find a single warm colour that White Sand loves.

Natural White

  • Natural White is friendlier with super cool colours, more so than White Sand. That’s because Natural White is a bit cleaner than White Sand.
  • Natural white prefers non-greens and caters more to cool colours with blue-violet in them.
  • Natural does NOT love warm colours…at all.

CLICK HERE OR ON THE ABOVE IMAGES FOR PACKAGES AND E-BOOKS

WHAT BENJAMIN MOORE OR SHERWIN WILLIAMS COLOUR IS SIMILAR TO WHITE SAND & NATURAL WHITE?

COMPARE COMPARE COMPARE! Even if you bounce between brands, comparison is the BEST way to see what’s going on in the colour you’re looking at. You’ll DEFINITELY want to compare White Sand and Natural White to each other and also check out Sherwin Williams Pure White

Kylie M Interiors Edesign, powder room, small bathroom with gray hexagon tile floor and green painted vanity with gold accents. Sherwin Williams Pure White. Online paint colour advice and blog

SUMMARY OF SHERWIN WILLIAMS WHITE SAND AND NATURAL WHITE

While these two whites have reasonably high LRV’s, because of their undertones and limitations in colour partners, I think they’re best used for:

  • wall and trim applications, meaning the wall and trim are painted the same colour as each other
  • when trying to find a white that will work with a variety of wall colours (warm-cool) throughout your home, I would NOT choose either of these whites

Next up…

The other OTHER whites

Sherwin Williams Emerald Designer Edition does have a few more whites. HOWEVER, if you’re painting trims and cabinets, these whites will be limiting. Why?

Well, when it comes to trim and cabinet colours, you need flexibility. You need whites that can humour a variety of finishes and paint colours and these whites don’t have much flexibility.

However, as it relates to WALL COLOURS, you can relax. Wall colours are often used on a room-by-room basis, which means you don’t always need as much flexibility compared to a colour that needs to humour a variety of rooms/paint colours/finishes (as is the case with trim colours and some cabinet colours).

6. Review of Sherwin Williams White Sail SW 9622

If you ask me, White Sail is Sherwin Williams answer to a NON-frigid icy blue-white. While White Sail is cool, it doesn’t have the crisp sharp edge that Extra White has. It’s also CLEANER AND COOLER than White Sand, with a bit more gray than Natural White.

LRV: White Sail has an LRV of 83. This makes it a VERY SOFT white, not quite an off-white, but nowhere near the bright or true range. However, cool whites like this can often LOOK a bit brighter, as their cold undertones come across cleaner in many lights, especially if you use certain light bulbs.

TYPE OF WHITE: White Sail is a cool white.

UNDERTONES: White Sail has a blue-violet undertone that’s very…very passive.

WHAT PAINT COLOURS WILL LOOK GOOD WITH WHITE SAIL?

If you’re considering White Sail, you’ll DEFINITELY want to be in the cool end of things – NO warm colours. As for cool colours, you should lean to the slightly cleaner, intense end of things vs. cool colours that are overly earth-toned.

WHAT BENJAMIN MOORE OR SHERWIN WILLIAMS COLOUR IS SIMILAR TO WHITE SAIL?

Comparison is key! Grab paint chips of each of these whites if you want to see where White Sail sits in comparison and notice any change in undertones.

These three whites have similar LRV’s and intentions to White Sail, making them great options/comparisons if you’re considering White Sail.

BENJAMIN MOORE DECORATORS WHITE (walls)

White vanity, white trim, marble countertop, Benjamin Moore Decorators White on walls in bathroom. Kylie M Interiors Edesign

7. Review of Sherwin Williams Frost Bite SW 9505

I see a LOT of potential in Frost Bite…but I also see a lot of undertones that will need to be accommodated.

LRV: Frost Bite has an LRV of 88, putting it closer to being a BRIGHT white than a soft one.

TYPE OF WHITE: There’s NO foolin’ around with this one – this is a WARM WHITE!

UNDERTONES: Frost Bite is anything but frostbitten with its yellow undertone.

WHAT PAINT COLOURS WILL LOOK GOOD WITH FROST BITE?

With having a higher LRV, Frost Bite will be more flexible than it would’ve been with a lower LRV. However, with its strong undertone, Frost Bite caters HARD to reasonably saturated warm paint colours. It actually reminds me a lot of the limitations associated with Sherwin Williams Dover White and the lighter Whitetail. That’s not to say Frost Bite won’t WORK with cool colours, however, you can expect the warmth of it to be ENHANCED by cool colours, and in turn, its warmth will enhance any cool colour or undertone.

WHAT BENJAMIN MOORE OR SHERWIN WILLIAMS COLOUR IS SIMILAR TO FROST BITE?

Comparison is the key to success when picking white paint colours, so take some time to check out Benjamin Moore Simply White, as shown on the trim, door and ceiling below…

Benjamin Moore Simply White , Collingwood gray walls, oak flooring, Kylie M Interiors Edesign, (3)

SUMMARY OF FROST BITE

My worry is that while Frost Bite will definitely have its place and is a stinkin’ gorgeous colour, it could be the ‘Dover White’ of the early 2020s. In other words, a colour that’s hard to work with when you want to make changes to your home in the future, as its undertones will be limiting.

8. Review of Sherwin Williams Snowbelt SW 9623

Snowbelt’s undertone is considerably stronger than that of Extra White and White Sail…combined. It is one COOOOL cucumber.

LRV: Snowbelt has an LRV of 87. While I appreciate this slightly higher LRV, its cool undertone is a force to be reckoned with!

TYPE OF WHITE: Snowbelt is definitely cool and crisp.

UNDERTONES: With its noticeable blue undertone, Snowbelt is not for the faint of heart and for THIS reason, I would never choose it as a whole home trim/cabinet/ceiling/door application.

WHAT PAINT COLOURS WILL LOOK GOOD WITH SNOWBELT?

With its strong undertone, Snowbelt will best suit cool colours that are no more than MODERATELY toned-down. For example, Sherwin Williams Tinsmith loves a cool white, but it’s too gray/muted for the clean look of Snowbelt. Sherwin Williams Tradewind, with its increased chroma, is more what Snowbelt is looking for in a partner.

Snowbelt also wants a committed blue undertone – no violet and only a SMIDGE of green can be mixed in.

WHAT BENJAMIN MOORE OR SHERWIN WILLIAMS COLOUR IS SIMILAR TO SNOWBELT?

Sherwin Williams Extra White is a great comparable for Snowbelt.

SHERWIN WILLIAMS EXTRA WHITE (trim)

Classic French Gray siding, Extra White and Stillwater front door. Exterior paint colour, pavers. Kylie M Interiors Edesign, online paint colour consultant. DIY decorating ideas blog. Best front door and exterior paint colors

SUMMARY OF SNOWBELT

With the slightly higher chroma (colour) of Snowbelt, I think it will be limited as to its use and I don’t see it being a huge hit. With the amount of undertone I see, Snowbelt might be more popular for:

Looking for the best gray to partner with one of the above whites? I’ve also done reviews on some of Sherwin William’s NEWEST gray paint colours from the Designer Edition line of paints, including…

Paint Colour Review of Sherwin Williams Touch of Grey

Paint Colour Review of Sherwin Williams Sweater Weather 

Paint Colour Review of Sherwin Williams Skipping Rocks

NEED HELP?

CHECK OUT MY ONLINE PAINT COLOUR CONSULTING AND E-BOOKS

-design and online paint colour consulting using Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams paint colors. Kylie M Interiors. DIY and affordable decorating advice blogger. Market

Chat soon,

Kylie M Interiors, decorating blog, e-design, online colour consulting expert. signature

READ MORE

The 5 Almost FOOL-PROOF White Paint Colours

The 5 Whitest White Paint Colours

The 5 TYPES of White Paint Colours

QUESTIONNAIRE: Should You Paint Your Cabinets or Stain Them?

How Light Bulbs Affect Paint Colours

How to Pick the Best White Paint Colour for Your Cabinets

The 7 Best White Paint Colours for a North-Facing Room

Sherwin Williams 4 Best White Paint Colours



Image

Comments

  1. Thank you SOOOOO much for this review, girl! I have been trying to get more info on these newer SW colors, especially the whites, and this helped me a TON. I am now going to paint all of my bedrooms & bonus room White Snow, using High Reflective White for the ceilings, doors, & trim. I will pick out accent wall colors later, but I just wanted to get a base coat down for now. I have a 2003 McMansion and it needs some major updating lol.
    Do you think the HRW & White Snow will look ok together?

  2. Thanks so much for reviewing these new colors! I actually chose White Snow for my bunk room in my new house. Once the built in bunks are done I’ll share some real life pics with you!

    1. Post
      Author

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More Posts

Meet Kylie

Thank you for visiting!  I'm so glad you're here!  Come on in to learn a little more about me!

Categories