Sherwin Williams Crushed Ice: Undertones, Lighting, LRV

By KylieMawdsley

September 19, 2025

If there’s one light gray paint color that’s highly underrated and underused, it has to be Sherwin Williams Crushed Ice. Why should it be one of the most popular shades of gray on the market? Let’s find out… 

WHAT TYPE OF COLOR IS CRUSHED ICE?

Crushed Ice is a warm paint color. But just because it’s warm doesn’t mean it’s remotely beige or cream; it’s actually a warm gray paint color. And just like every other gray, it has undertones (which we’ll get into shortly).

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I make a small commission (at no extra cost to you) on any purchases you make through clicking a link on this site. See my full disclosure here.

Like death, taxes, and cellulite – undertones are darn hard to avoid. 

However, Crushed Ice isn’t traditionally warm by any stretch of the imagination. In fact, I’m more inclined to call it ‘warmy stormy’ (super technical).

Sherwin Williams Crushed Ice, Pure White trim, black spindles in stairs, light wood flooring. Kylie M Interiors Edesign

What’s a ‘warmy stormy’ gray?

Most popular warm gray paint colors are obviously warm, and most cool ones are obviously cool. However, while Crushed Ice has warmth in it, it sure as heck ain’t obvious about it.

This means that in a room with cool northern light, Crushed Ice can lean into its cool base and cool undertones a bit more. However, in a room with southern sun or afternoon western light, you’ll see it soften up – maybe not looking WARM, but definitely leaning this way.

Sherwin Williams Crushed Ice with southwest exposure in windows. Pure White trim, Kylie M Interiors Edesign

North, East, South, West – Which Paint Color is the Best?

99.5% of the photos in my blog are from my Online Color Consulting clients, readers, talented photographers, & friends— because real homes deserve to be celebrated (dirty laundry & all!) While not magazine-perfect, they’re packed with timeless home update ideas & proven, popular paint color choices to help you create a home you’ll love.

WHAT’S THE LRV OF CRUSHED ICE?

Crushed Ice has an LRV of 66, so it’s smack dab in the middle of the ‘light’ range, making it a great option for a range of spaces. In fact, the 60-70 range is pretty normal for the average home/room.

While pairing warm and cool finishes together can be challenging, as many warm colors clash with cooler and lighter shades, we managed to incorporate Crushed Ice quite nicely in this next home…

family room or living room before remodel beige stone fireplace (1)

Before (above), the red paint color overwhelmed the beautiful stone fireplace. After (below), Crushed Ice works well with the limestone fireplace and drastically brightens the space…

Living room or family room, stone fireplace that's beige with Sherwin Williams Crushed Ice grey paint colour walls, Pure White trim and mantel. Kylie M Interiors Edesign

However, with its slightly higher LRV, Crushed Ice washes out on well-lit walls. That said, you need to add more depth to any color so that it doesn’t wash out. If you have a basement or dark room, it can look a bit dingy, simply because it’s a warm gray, not a fresh or clean one.

Not sure what LRV is? It could save your paint lovin’ life – read all about it HERE.

WHAT ARE CRUSHED ICE’S UNDERTONES?

While Crushed Ice isn’t crushin’ hard on its undertones, they’re there. Some people choose Crushed Ice, thinking it’s one of the most neutral gray paint colors, but it’s not. Crushed Ice has a soft green undertone, but with the right interior lighting or exposure, it can easily flash slightly green-blue or even a tiny wink purple (not as common).

One thing I love about Crushed Ice is that often, it looks pretty neutral – not committing to one undertone or another. 

Entryway in Crushed Ice before painting

These flexible undertones make it a great choice for a space that doesn’t need committed undertones, but tricky with finishes that DEMAND a visible purple, blue, or green.

Here’s your Peel & Stick sample of Crushed Ice (on your front door, tomorrow!)

sherwin crushed Ice paint color review with Kylie M

WHAT’S THE BEST WHITE TRIM OR CABINET COLOR WITH SW CRUSHED ICE?

Crushed Ice is pretty darn fussy about its white paint color partners and won’t favor those with too much warmth. Instead, I’d explore…

The 4 Best White Paint Colors from Sherwin Williams

WHERE DOES CRUSHED ICE LOOK ITS BEST?

Not all colors are cut out for the same job, and Crushed Ice certainly has its limitations.

Sherwin Williams Crushed Ice, Pure White trim, black spindles in stairs, light wood flooring. Kylie M Interiors Edesign

CRUSHED ICE AS AN EXTERIOR COLOR

Generally speaking, no, it’s not a popular exterior color as it’s less likely to suit the average stone, brick, or roof color.

DOES CRUSHED ICE GO WITH CREAM CABINETS & TRIMS?

That’s a hard no – in fact, it’s so hard, I’m getting a little excited. Crushed Ice will be downright fugly with cream cabinets and trims.

HOW ABOUT WOOD FINISHES?

Crushed Ice can be really pretty with a range of wood finishes, especially if separated by white trim (in the case of wood flooring). In particular, I like it with softer, lighter woods with a yellow hue.

5 Tips for Choosing an Exterior Paint Color

WHAT PAINT COLORS ARE SIMILAR TO CRUSHED ICE?

Sampling and comparing similar paint colors is one of the MOST IMPORTANT parts of your color journey – you might find something you love even more!

CRUSHED ICE VS. FIRST STAR

These two colors are fun to compare, as First Star helps show off the warmer backdrop of Crushed Ice.

Living room, extra white trim, mantle, marble fireplace surround, blue-green sofas, Sherwin Williams First Star gray blue walls, wood floor, round dining table

*Also, Sherwin Williams site says First Star is a white – it’s not white. Compare it to SW High Reflective White to see the shift. 

This is because First Star is a more standard-looking cool gray paint color that favors a bit more blue over green. As for depth, First Star’s LRV of 69 is lighter than Crushed Ice’s 66 – about 25% lighter.

Sherwin Williams First Star Paint Color Review

CRUSHED ICE VS SHERWIN WILLIAMS GOSSAMER VEIL

This comparison is cool, as while First Star shows the warmth of Crushed Ice, Gossamer Veil shows how gray it can be!

Benjamin Moore Gossamer Veil in guest bedroom, white metal headboard, blue gray accents, White Dove shiplap accent wall. Kylie M Interiors Edesign

Gossamer Veil headboard wall with Benjamin Moore White Dove shiplap wall

This is because Gossamer Veil is warmer than First Star. While Gossamer Veil is also a warm gray, it leans more to greige with a very (very) vague green undertone.

Gossamer Veil is also darker than Crushed Ice, with an LRV of 62.

Sherwin Williams Gossamer Veil Paint Color Review

WHAT ARE SIMILAR ALTERNATIVES IN BENJAMIN MOORE?

If you love the look of Crushed Ice but need it in Benjamin Moore paint, there are colors with ‘similar intentions’, but nothing exactly the same. In fact, more so than some colors, there isn’t anything even ‘really’ close.

Beige, off-white sofa in den with Benjamin Moore Gray Owl paint color on walls, white trim, blue home decor

Benjamin Moore Gray Owl

However, you should still check out Benjamin Moore Gray Owl and Moonshine to see if you like their different approach.

WHAT COLORS GO WITH CRUSHED ICE IN A PALETTE?

While it depends on what you need these colors for – accent wall, cabinets, kitchen island, or inside your front door – these will get you started.

READ MORE

The Best WHOLE HOME Taupe & Greige Paint Colors

Paint Color Review: Sherwin Williams Big Chill

Paint Color Review: Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray

Get the best paint color advice

Check out my Online Paint Color Consulting – I’d love to help!

The best paint colors for your room. Benjamin and Sherwin. Kylie M Interiors Edesign, online paint colour consulting. Home Decorating and diy ideas blogger.market

ORIGINALLY WRITTEN IN 2021, UPDATED FOR FRESH, NEW CONTENT IN LATE 2025

Tagged with:

Meet Kylie

Do you need help, but aren’t quite sure what ‘help’ looks like? Are you drowning in paint samples and decision fatigue?

Does every color you like at the paint store look terrible in your lighting or pick up a funky undertone? I’d love to help.

Samplize Peel and Stick Paint Samples

Hi, I’m Kylie

For over 24 years I’ve helped 12,000+ homeowners and renters make more confident decisions on paint colors and affordable home updates using real home examples and practical, experience-based advice. My goal is simple: help you love the home you have.

Do-it-yourself, the smart way

I wrote these for you!

A collection of e-books I’ve written to help with everything from paint colors to home decor.

  • Learn how to design and choose paint colors online guides, ebooks, courses, by Kylie M Interiors

    Collection – White Paint Colors

    Learn everything you need to know about white paint colors…and then some.

    3 PDFs | Instant Download

    This post may contain affiliate links, which means I make a small commission (at no extra cost to you) on any purchases you make through clicking a link on this site. See my full disclosure here.

    $99.99
    More details
  • Home Staging Kylie M

    Home Staging for Beginners

    Simple steps to prepare your home to sell

    124 Page PDF | Instant Download

    This post may contain affiliate links, which means I make a small commission (at no extra cost to you) on any purchases you make through clicking a link on this site. See my full disclosure here.

    $24.99
    More details
  • ONLINE COURSES, GUIDES, OR EBOOKS HOW TO DECORATE, CHOOSE WHITE PAINT COLORS, DECORATE, BY KYLIE M INTERIORS

    It’ll Be All White: 3-Part Series

    The absolute ultimate guide to white paint colors.

    3 Part Series – 279 Total Pages | Instant Downloads

    This post may contain affiliate links, which means I make a small commission (at no extra cost to you) on any purchases you make through clicking a link on this site. See my full disclosure here.

    $49.99
    More details
  • LEARN HOW TO DECORATE AND DESIGN ONLINE WITH KYLIE M INTERIORS. COLOR CONSULTANT, DECORATING, AND MORE

    Complete Home Color & Decorating Library

    Paint colors, decorating, design, and so much more. Have fun with your own personal library of practical and budget-friendly home updates!

    $199.99
    More details
  • how to home stage to get ready to sell and home decor online guides and ebooks by Kylie M Interiors

    Collection – Home Staging

    Get your home ready to sell, then get ready to settle into your new home with these 2 fun guides.

    2 PDFs | Instant Download

    This post may contain affiliate links, which means I make a small commission (at no extra cost to you) on any purchases you make through clicking a link on this site. See my full disclosure here.

    $49.99
    More details
  • ebook or online guide to learn how to decorate, home deor, and add accents colors by Kylie M

    Collection – Decorating & Design

    Practical ideas and guidance to help your home feel more like you – without spending a fortune

    $49.99
    More details
  • how to choose exterior paint colors and trim collection online guide and ebook learning with Kylie M INteriors

    Collection – Exterior Paint Colors

    Learn how to choose your best exterior paint color and coordinating trim with these 2 guides, designed to make choosing paint colors fun!

    $89.99
    More details
  • A Little More Like Home Kylie M

    A Little More Like Home

    A homeowner’s guide to DIY decorating and design.

    240 Page PDF | Instant Download

    This post may contain affiliate links, which means I make a small commission (at no extra cost to you) on any purchases you make through clicking a link on this site. See my full disclosure here.

    $39.99
    More details

Comments

  1. Bailey Avatar
    Bailey

    Hi Kylie!

    We’re building a home that has TONS of white cabinets, backsplash, and trim. We are thinking about crushed ice for all over wall color. We like warm neutrals but do not want white walls. Would crushed ice be a good option?

    1. Kylie M Avatar
      Kylie M

      Wellll, I wouldn’t say that Crushed Ice is TERRIBLY warm, but if it feels warm enough for you, it’s pretty!

  2. Yael Avatar
    Yael

    I painted the main floor of my midcentury split-level Crushed Ice last year based in part on your review, and it’s GORGEOUS! Floors are unstained white oak and trim is Extra White because that’s what I already had on hand, and after using Samplize to compare it with the whites you suggested, I liked it just as much. Accents and furniture are gold, black, soft gray and mixed neutrals in tones that work. Wanted to come back here to thank you SO much. I love your work and website!

    1. Kylie M Avatar
      Kylie M

      What a great comment to read – thank YOU! I’m so glad you found colors you love :).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Let’s do this together

Ready to love the home you have?

Skip the overwhelm and the expensive mistakes. Get a personal, easy-to-follow color plan completed online in three easy steps.

Trusted by 12,000+ clients · results in 8–10 business days