Benjamin Moore Abalone & Barren Plain: LRV’s, Undertones and a Little More
Are you looking for a gorgeous neutral gray paint color? Well, you’ve come to the WRONG place! Because while Benjamin Moore Abalone and Barren Plain certainly have gray in them, they’ve got a few OTHER things too, which we’re going to take a closer look at today.
In order to show you RELATEABLE & REAL homes, I ONLY use photos from my Online Color Consulting clients, which means I don’t always have the pics I need. So, while I don’t have a ton of images of Barren Plain, in particular, I do have some SUPER helpful info to help you on your way.
What type of paint colors are Abalone and Barren Plain? Are they warm or cool grays?
Both Abalone and Barren Plain are WARM GRAY paint colors, however, whereas Barren Plain is ‘slightly warm’, Abalone almost hits the taupe end of things with an extra dose of brown mixed in.
Benjamin Moore Abalone in north-east light
- If you partner north-facing light with Abalone, it will lean back a bit grayer, while still holding a decent warmth (as shown above). If you have south-facing or afternoon western sunshine, it may lean a bit warmer/more taupe than you might expect
- If you have north-facing light, Barren Plain will look cooler and you may notice the undertone a bit more. If you have south-facing or afternoon western sunshine, it will lean a bit warmer without going totally taupe
Read more: North, East, South, West – Which Paint Color is the Best?
What are the LRV’s of Abalone and Barren Plain?
Abalone’s LRV sits at 63.06, while Barren Plain has an LRV of 63.16. These comparable LRV’s mean they’re essentially the same depth and are BOTH in the light depth range.
Benjamin Moore Abalone in north-east light
Not sure what LRV is? It could save your paint lovin’ life – read all about it HERE.
What are the undertones of Abalone and Barren Plain? Will my walls look purple or pink?
Wellllll, it depends on how sensitive you are…
- Abalone has a considerably WARM PURPLE undertone, meaning it’s more of a purple-pink. If you have south-facing light this could show up to the party a bit more
- Barren Plain has a slightly warm purple undertone, meaning it’s WAY less likely to go purple-pink on you, but again, the undertone is not terribly SUBTLE (if you ask me, but if you LOVE purple, you might disagree – it might not be ENOUGH!)
Abalone with south-west light
Long story short, if you’re sensitive to purple undertones, I wouldn’t choose either of these colors and would read this instead. If you’re looking for a relatively neutral gray, again, these aren’t those types of colors and you’ll want to look elsewhere.
If you LOVE purple undertones, you may want to check out Benjamin Moore Cement Gray and Portland Gray as well. I
What’s the best way to sample paint colors?
Like with every paint color, I highly recommend using SAMPLIZE. Samplize is a peel & stick paint sample that you can easily move around your room for over HALF THE COST of traditional sample pots – and they deliver right to your front door!
Learn all about Samplize HERE
If I’m painting my walls Abalone or Barren Plain, what’s the best white paint color for my trim?
I’ve found that both Abalone and Barren Plain prefer a cleaner white approach. If you partner them with too warm of a white, the yellow of the warm white will clash with the purple undertones of these paint colors. Instead, I would sample…
- Benjamin Moore Chantilly Lace
- Benjamin Moore Oxford White
Benjamin Moore’s 8 Best White Paint Colors
SHOULD I Paint My Wood Cabinets White? A QUESTIONNAIRE
Are Abalone or Barren Plain good colors for the exterior of my home?
I’m not going to say no…but I’m very very hesitant to say yes. These gray paint colors have MORE UNDERTONE than not and the color WILL show up to the party on the exterior of your home, so you better be ready for it!
Read more: 5 Tips to Choosing an Exterior Paint Color
Are Abalone and Barren Plain popular gray paint colors?
For those wanting a decent purple undertone, Abalone and Barren Plain are top tier, however, MOST of my Online Paint Color Consulting clients are going for a more subtle approach.
What Sherwin Williams paint colors are the same as or similar to Abalone and Barren Plain?
Every color has its own particular nuances and there will be NO perfect match – you WILL see shifts in undertones, temperature and depths. USUALLY, I have some ‘reasonable’ comparables, but not this time. The closest I got was Sherwin Williams Egret White (to Abalone).
Instead, I’d encourage you to check out some more MUTED gray options with similar undertones like Benjamin Moore Classic Gray and Balboa Mist.
Benjamin Moore Balboa Mist
Benjamin Moore Classic Gray
And if you’re thinking of color matching between brands (ie: getting Benjamin Moore to make a Sherwin Williams paint color), you might want to read THIS first.
What type of paint colors look good with Abalone and Barren Plain?
When it comes to putting these colors in a palette, you can consider some…
- Darker slightly warm or reasonably warm grays with purple undertones
- Darker grays (darker than Abalone and Barren Plain) with a gray-blue or gray-green undertone can be really interesting partners to these colors
- Light soft gray paint colors with reasonably strong blue or green undertones
- Some subtle, off-white paint colors
Not sure if Abalone or Barren Plain are right for you?
SHERWIN WILLIAMS ON THE ROCKS
Read more: Paint Color Review of Sherwin Williams On the Rocks
BENJAMIN MOORE COLLINGWOOD
Read more: Paint Color Review of Benjamin Moore Collingwood
BENJAMIN MOORE CLASSIC GRAY
Read more: Paint Color Review of Benjamin Moore Classic Gray
Not sure which paint color is best for YOUR home?
Check out my Online Paint Color Consulting – I’d love to help!
Hi Kylie! We are repainting the entire inside of our home and based on your recommendations I have chosen Edgecomb gray and revere pewter as my all over color palette with white dove for the trim. This color palette is for the downstairs. I love it with my porcelain floors. My upstairs media room has dark wood floors with a significant red hue. I read one of your other blogs and you suggested Abalone as a color that would go well with that color flooring. It is a south facing room with a good amount light. Any other suggestions for colors for that room? Thanks! Love your website and videos! They have been so helpful! I’ve learned so much about paint!
You are a genius for putting Abalone in that dining area with the double doors. Wow it makes that whole room — well it makes the whole room *everything* — updated, elegant, cohesive, creating a palate with the wood color as the secondary room color.
I love everything you do, Kylie. Just had to reach out and say it once!
By the way we see colors exactly the same way. Every time I’m thinking I see green . . .two beats later you say “I’m seeing a little green in this”. Haha. Best always.
What a lovely comment to get, Cathleen, THANK YOU!