Home → The Best Paint Colours → Colours → The 8 Best Benjamin Moore Green Paint Colours

The 8 Best Benjamin Moore Green Paint Colours

Posted on January 2, 2022 by KylieMawdsley

The Top 8 Shades of Green: Benjamin Moore

Partner Post to The Best Blue-Green (Teal) Paint Colours

Many of us get the chills just thinking about painting our homes a cool colour like blue, violet or green. And while there are many cool colours that will give a ‘cool and crisp’ feeling, there are others that can look warmer due in part to their depth and undertone. It’s all about picking the right colour for the job.

WHERE DO GREEN PAINT COLOURS WORK THE BEST?

SOUTH-FACING ROOMS

In rooms where the sun beats in relentlessly, cool colours like green can help balance the ‘visual’ temperature of the space. Learn more about south-facing rooms here: The Best Paint Colours for South-Facing Rooms.

ROOMS WITH A LOT OF WOOD

If you LOVE your wood cabinets, flooring or furniture, you might love how green will ‘accent’ your wood pieces, whereas a warm colour would blend in with your wood tones. Read ALLLL about this here: The Best Paint Colours to Update Wood Finishes

The Top Benjamin Moore Green Paint Colours

(Including some greens with a touch of blue/gray undertone)

1. BENJAMIN MOORE ARCTIC SHADOWS

Arctic Shadows is for those of you who love green but don’t want to make too much of a STATEMENT about it.

While Arctic Shadows is OBVIOUSLY green, it has a neutral base to calm it down, making it a stronger earth tone.

Mountain Air has an LRV of 53.58. Not sure what LRV is? It could save your paint lovin’ life (HERE).

PAINT COLOURS THAT ARE SIMILAR TO ARTIC SHADOWS

Sherwin Williams Rare Gray has a similar approach to Arctic Shadows

2. BENJAMIN MOORE ANTIQUE PEWTER 1560

Antique Pewter is a medium-toned green paint colour with a soft neutral base calming it down – essentially making it a darker version of Arctic Shadows. This is a SLIGHTLY warm green, but more modern looking than a traditional olive green.

Antique Pewter has an LRV of 24.15, so it’s tucked nicely in the medium range with some good meat on its bones.

PAINT COLOURS THAT ARE SIMILAR TO ANTIQUE PEWTER

Benjamin Moore Crownsville Gray. A bit more of a rich, slightly darker take on Antique Pewter
Benjamin Moore Copley Gray. It’s like taking MOST of the green out of Antique Pewter, leaving more of a greige look with subtle undertones

3. BENJAMIN MOORE FERNWOOD GREEN 2145-40

Fernwood Green is a beauty. It doesn’t have that modern gray-green-blue blend that you’ll find in a lot of today’s paint colours as it’s in the LEGIT green zone with a wink of warmth.

Fernwood Green is just slightly warm without getting too funky about it and would add a bit of life to a north-facing room especially. With its LRV of 57.98, it’s a light depth paint colour, but one with a BIT more body compared to ones closer to my MAGICAL LRV number.

Similar to Fernwood Green in southern or afternoon western sun

North, East, South, West – Which Paint Colour is the Best?

PAINT COLOURS THAT ARE SIMILAR TO FERNWOOD GREEN

Benjamin Moore Dill Pickle. One of my faves as it’s a slightly more funk-da-fied warm green
Benjamin Moore Camouflage. Still a warm green but it has a more neutral base, making it earth-toned

4. BENJAMIN MOORE NANTUCKET GRAY HC-111

Nantucket Gray is GORGEOUS if you want an earth-toned, muted, but still green look on your walls.

Nantucket Gray has an LRV of 39.49, so while it’s got some depth to it, it’s not a HEAVY medium tone. If you haven’t touched up on LRV yet, I highly recommend you do HERE.

PAINT COLOURS THAT ARE SIMILAR TO NANTUCKET GRAY

Benjamin Moore Jockey Hollow Gray. Similar, but less ‘colour’
Benjamin Moore October Mist. A cleaner look than Nantucket with less greige in it

5. BENJAMIN MOORE CAROLINA GULL 2138-40

Seriously, I have mad love for Carolina Gull. Whether it’s a bathroom, kitchen, living room or stairwell – this colour never fails to impress! Women often love this colour as it’s almost like a modern, more grayed-out version of teal (which is a popular accent). Men love this colour because they tend to love green, blue and gray, and this colour is a fantastic blend of those three. Predominantly green, with a decent gray, then a submissive blue undertone.

Carolina Gull has an LRV of 26.37, so he’s a solid fella.

PAINT COLOURS THAT ARE SIMILAR TO CAROLINA GULL

Benjamin Moore Caribbean Teal. Just like Carolina Gull, but with considerably less gray and more COLOUR!
Benjamin Moore Heather Gray. Very close, just more gray, really

Undoubtedly, you’ll be heading out in the near future to grab paint samples – stop right there! I want you to check out SAMPLIZE. Samplize offers peel and stick paint samples that are more AFFORDABLE, EASIER and more ENVIRONMENTALLY FRIENDLY than traditional paint pots. Here are just a FEW reasons why I recommend Samplize to my clients…

samples arrive ON YOUR DOORSTEP in 1-3 business days, depending on the location
they’re more affordable than the samples pots/rollers/foam boards that are needed for traditional paint sampling
if you keep the samples on their white paper, you can move them around the room

Visit the SAMPLIZE website HERE

6. BENJAMIN MOORE JOCKEY HOLLOW GRAY HC 108

Jockey Hollow Gray is a GORGEOUS colour for bedrooms as it’s restful and relaxing and beautiful with woods like fir and cedar. Its blend of green and greige makes for a soft, grounded looking green that hovers right between the colour/neutral worlds – it would be open to interpretation for sure. Gettysburg Gray is the slightly darker version, adding depth and therefore, subtle warmth to any room.

Sandy Hook Gray has an LRV of 38.79, so it’s a medium-toned paint colour. Gettysburg Gray has an LRV of 29.92, so it’s a solid tone darker.

PAINT COLOURS THAT ARE SIMILAR TO JOCKEY HOLLOW GRAY & GETTYSBURG GRAY

Benjamin Moore Rockport Gray. Same idea, but a bit more of a taupe base which cuts back on a lot of the green and can flash slightly purple at times
Benjamin Moore Clarksville Gray. The warmer cousin to Jockey Hollow, with a bit more beige/less gray in it

The 15 Best Paint Colours to go with Wood

7. BENJAMIN MOORE DRY SAGE 2142-40

Dry Sage is a gorgeous soft gray-green blend. It leans a bit more to the warm side, but not enough to make it SUPER olive toned or greige. It also leans MORE into green than it does its neutral base.

Dry Sage has an LRV of 34.1 – medium depth for sure.

PAINT COLOURS THAT ARE SIMILAR TO DRY SAGE

Benjamin Moore Gray Mirage. The lighter version of Dry Sage (mad love)
Benjamin Moore Cheyenne Green. Like a slightly lighter, more muted/less green Dry Sage

8. BENJAMIN MOORE CALDWELL GREEN HC-124

Caldwell Green is a bit more GREEN and a bit darker than many of the above colours – but daaang, is she ever gorgeous. With an LRV of 16, Caldwell Green is a medium-dark green paint colour. And while there’s a BIT of gray in there to calm it down, you’re still left with a whole lot of glorious green.

Caldwell Green looks MUCH more green on these upper cabinets via the natural light, interior lighting and photography. But if you take a good look at those lower cabinets, you’ll see a bit more typical shot of Caldwell in action.

Oh, you know I can’t even help myself – let’s do another one…

9. BENJAMIN MOORE NOVEMBER RAIN 2142-60

I didn’t touch much on the LIGHTER range with the above colours as MOST of my clients who are wanting green, want one with a bit of meat on its bones!

However, something must be said for the beauty of a soft, gentle green like November Rain. With an LRV of 71, November Rain is on the HIGH end of the light range – winking at off-white. It’s also a WARM green with a greige base to calm it down.

THE BEST DARKER GREEN PAINT COLOURS TO CHECK OUT

To hit a nice range, we’re looking at Benjamin Moore AND Sherwin William’s popular shades of green.

Benjamin Moore Ashwood
Benjamin Moore Narragansett Green & (a lot of blue in these)
Benjamin Moore Artichoke
Benjamin Moore Tarrytown Green (relatively legit)
Benjamin Moore Salamander (cool and DARK!)
Sherwin Williams Hunt Club (legit green)
Sherwin Williams Ripe Olive
Sherwin Williams Rock Bottom
Sherwin Williams Jasper
Sherwin Williams Shade-Grown

A FEW MORE POPULAR LIGHT GREEN PAINT COLOURS TO EXPLORE

Mountain Air is a soft, warm green with a gray-greige base to calm it down. It’s a light-medium colour depth colour with a slightly fresh vibe.
Benjamin Moore Spanish Olive is just a WEE wink warmer than Mountain Air – a great comparison.
Benjamin Moore Camouflage. Camouflage is a beautiful WARM green paint colour with a soft greige base to calm it down.

And for a bit of FUN, let’s look at this gorgeous mudroom in Benjamin Moore Avon Green! Before, the room was flat with a heavy cabinet and murky walls, but my client wanted to keep ALL of the existing green surfaces while freshening up the space…

With a fresh coat of paint on the walls and door and the removal of the honky cabinet above the sink, the room looks SO much better (the pictures will be hung shortly).

Now, if you love the IDEA of those, but find them a bit too green, you might want to check out the gray or greige range with green undertones, something like Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter for example.

The 8 Best Blue Green Blend Paint Colours

Paint Colour Review: Sherwin Williams Evergreen Fog

North, East, South, West: Which Paint Colours is the Best?

The Best WHOLE HOME Gray and Greige Paint Colours

Looking for a great green?

Check out my Online Color Consulting for your own personal consultation!

ORIGINALLY WRITTEN IN 2019, TOTALLY OVERHAULED IN 2022

Comments

Janet
March 10, 2013 at 11:20 am

Hi, Kylie: Found a duvet cover I just love some time ago, but have been struggling to find just the right grey to go with it. Now I think that Sandy Hook grey might just fit the bill. Will pick up a test jar this week and give it a try. Thanks.
Janet

Reply
1. Kylie Mawdsley
  March 14, 2013 at 5:25 pm
  
  I loooove Sandy Hook Gray – I hope you try it!!!
  
  Reply
shea
July 8, 2013 at 10:15 am

I’m looking for a very light purple for my daughters bedroom from bm. Any suggestions?
Thanks

Reply
1. Kylie Mawdsley
  July 9, 2013 at 12:41 pm
  
  Hi Shea, I just finished a little girls room in Lily Lavender and it’s just beautiful! When paired with white furniture it’s cute as a button. I think my fave soft purple would be Beach Plum as it’s soft and purple without being bright. If I were to do my daughters’ rooms purple (aged 4 and 7) I would choose either Beach Plum or Lily Lavender….If you want something even softer then you could look at Misty Lilac. Raspberry ice is also comparible but that type of purple in it’s lightest end looks a little washy to me. I hope that helps, please holler with any more questions and send before and after photos!!!!
  
  Reply
  1. Brenda
    March 9, 2018 at 4:23 pm
    
    Queen Anne Lilac! Sherwin Williams. I painted my bedroom walls. Just finishing the woodwork with original white. SW. STUNNINGLY SOFT
    
    Reply
    1. Lynne
      November 13, 2019 at 10:50 am
      
      My bedroom at my old house was painted this color! Loved it. Going to use it again in our new house.
      
      Reply
Sarah
September 13, 2013 at 10:29 pm

Kylie — What do you think of Palladian Blue for a small bathroom? (Silver fixtures, lt. cool beige floor and counters and white shower tile.) It’s now painted Olive Green which I find too dark and a bit of a downer. I prefer the feeling of more refreshing greens/blues.

Reply
1. Kylie Mawdsley
  September 14, 2013 at 10:27 am
  
  Hi Sarah! I think Palladian Blue could be gorgeous – and certainly more refreshing than olive green! I JUST finished writing a post on a bathroom that sounds like it has ‘very similar’ things going on. I’m going to post it. If you’re a subscriber you’ll get the update. If not, just check out my blog later today and you’ll see it – it turned out SOOO beautiful and we used a colour called Gray Cashmere – looooovely soft colour. Let me know what you think and always feel free to send photos if you need any other help or want to show me anything – I love before and afters!!!!!!
  
  Reply
Bria Moreno
October 12, 2013 at 1:18 pm

Hello, I am going to be using Templeton Gray for the accent wall in my living room, can you provide any names of colors that would work well for the main color in the living room?

Reply
1. Kylie Mawdsley
  October 12, 2013 at 2:37 pm
  
  I love Templeton Gray, I had it in my master bedroom for a while! You could try it with Muslin for a fresh, but still neutral look or Palace White for a slightly more fresh and bright look….hope that helps!!
  
  Reply
Patty
November 18, 2013 at 7:32 pm

Hello I’m in a color dilemma. I painted my kitchen and dinning room Palladian blue open concept what color do you think would tie pretty together in my living room. I love the palladian blue could take this color throughout my entire house but I was thinking that might be too much. I have super dark furniture and floors are dark as well so it looks AWESOM! Any color ideas would be greatly appreciated. My trim work is bright white so I wanted something that will make it POP. Not into drab colors. Thank you!!!

Reply
Beth
February 28, 2014 at 12:27 pm

Hi Kylie. I love your ideas and creativity! We just painted our kitchen Benjamin Moore Lenox Tan and the dining room Benjamin Moore Carolina Gull (both Sherwin Williams custom match colors). Now we’re getting ready to paint the laundry room. We wanted to paint this room a shade of blue. The ceiling, trim and cabinets are white and the counter top has a mixture of cream, grey and tan. I really like BM Palladian Blue, but I’m thinking it might be too light compared to the other two paint colors we just used. So then I thought maybe Sherwin Williams Interesting Aqua 6220, Meditative 6227 or Jubilee 6248 might look better. What do you think? Or, do you have other suggestions? Thank you.

Reply
1. Kylie Mawdsley
  February 28, 2014 at 12:45 pm
  
  Hi Beth, great quick question! Normally I refer people to my Online Consulting, but you caught me at a good time 🙂
  
  Okay, so I LOOOVE Carolina Gull almost as much as I love Palladian Blue, however Palladian Blue is in a slightly different colour family from Carolina Gull, also the blue of it is a tough sell with the green of Carolina Gull. So, if you want that ‘look’ but in a colour family that is better suited to Lenox and Carolina then you’ll want to check out these….
  
  1. Prescott Green. More green than Palladian and still not quite in the same colour family, but it’s the green in it that is a bit more compatible with Carolina (although I like Palladian better, Prescott is still pretty)
  
  2. Blue Grass. Just a weeee bit lighter than Palladian with a tiny tiny bit more gray in it – making it a slightly better fit
  
  3. Flora (an Aura b.m. colour) is an AMAZING colour. Now it’s closer to Carolina Gull than not (so you could have it lightened by 1/4) however I’ve seen this one in action and it flees throughout the day between greeny blue and then to bluey green – it’s pretty awesome!
  
  4. Purple tones also look great opposite Carolina Gull and while purple isn’t everyone’s thing it does look great with grays (like in your countertop). Check out Gull Wing Gray as it’s gray with a purple undertone with a WEEEEE bit of blue in it – making it not obnoxiously purple. Just humour me 😉
  
  I hope that helps you out!!!
  
  ~Kylie
  
  Reply
Val
April 25, 2014 at 11:28 am

I’m hanging on your every word here, and I appreciate this blog. I’m wondering if you have words on colors you would chose for a finished basement. So–rooms with just a little bit of natural light, functioning as family rooms, rec rooms, laundry rooms, etc. And rooms in the basement that get no light at all. Warm mid-tone colors? Or maybe they can do with darker jewel tones? Thanks!

Reply
1. Kylie Mawdsley
  May 19, 2014 at 9:08 am
  
  Great question Val, I will be writing a post shortly on this topic that will hopefully give you some enlightenment! Chat soon! ~Kylie
  
  Reply
Sarah McKay
November 23, 2014 at 2:24 pm

HI Kylie,

I have started painting using Gray Shower which my husband and I love. I have used it sparingly as it is pretty strong. The co-ordinating color on the Ben Moore website is Smoke, which is the predominate color that I love but my husband finds a bit blah! I have tried to explain to him that too much of the Gray Shower will be too dark and heavy in our open plan living area. We have an orangey (Buttered Yam kinda color) leather couch and 2 recliner chairs. I think that that color combination works really very well. But in an attempt to compromise is there a color in the blue family that you could suggest and that we can both live with…
Thanks so much.

Reply
1. Kylie Mawdsley
  November 28, 2014 at 12:00 pm
  
  Hi Sarah, I would SO love to help but I get quite inundated with Online Questions and actually offer Affordable Online Consulting for questions just like yours so that I can see photos of your space and spend some quality time coming up with solutions for you! For $40 I could give you 2-3 paint colour options along with explanations so you can understand why certain colours might/might not work for you and hubby.
  Thank you for asking! https://www.kylieminteriors.ca/online-decorating-design-services/
  ~Kylie
  
  Reply
Erin M
March 21, 2015 at 9:52 pm

i just found this post in pinterest. I was planning on painting some of my rooms blue and green. This is so helpful, you just made it really easy. I’ve never seen anyone use the paint chip and then the painted room. Awesome!! Thank you.

Reply
1. Kylie Mawdsley
  March 22, 2015 at 10:09 am
  
  I’m glad you found it helpful and hope you found a few faves!
  
  Chat soon,
  
  ~Kylie
  
  Reply
gloria pauley
June 12, 2015 at 11:27 am

What blue gray do you feel would look best on an island and mantle stove surround in a kitchen? Love Florentine plaster, Heather Gray and others you show. Just not sure which wood be best on furniture.

Reply
1. Kylie Mawdsley
  June 14, 2015 at 2:49 pm
  
  Hi Gloria! Definitely not Florentine Plaster as it is a green/gray/beige, without blue. Heather Gray is lovely but again would come up more green than not. If it were me and I were looking for a subtle blue/gray for an island/mantle stove surround I might check out: Duxbury Gray – a nice stoney blue/gray that isn’t as icy as many blue/grays can be or for a darker more dramatic look, check out Sherwin Williams Wall Street. Now a BM colour like Piedmont Gray is a mix of blue/gray/green which might make you happy but compared to your original choices it will feel quite blue. I hope that helps, or maybe you just realized that you prefer green/grays, not blue grays!
  
  ~Kylie
  
  Reply
Tina
August 27, 2015 at 12:26 pm

HI Kylie. I am leaning towards Sandy Hook gray for a dining room that has wainscoting. It is a north facing room with just one window. The rest of the house is fairly neutral in SW colonnade gray/BM pale oak, so I want something a little darker with a green undertone. If you are familiar with Gettysburg gray vs Sandy Hook would you recommend one over the other? SW Ethereal Mood was the only other I considered that seemed close. THANKS!

Tina

Reply
1. Kylie Mawdsley
  August 29, 2015 at 1:47 pm
  
  Hi Tina, I would lean toward Sandy Hook Gray over Gettysburg, mostly because it’s a North facing room with lower lower light. Sandy Hook will definitely have that lovely subtle green undertone and the visual weight of it sits nicely with Collonade while being about a tone darker, which is nice.
  Hope that helps!
  ~Kylie
  
  Reply
Sara Poor
January 20, 2018 at 6:24 am

Have you done a Blog on your favorite coastal/beachy colors? I’m gathering a palette of Benjamin Moore paints to repaint my entire home. My vision is: blue, green, aqua/teal, driftwood gray/brown, sandy brown/tan, and a creamy off- white for trim and maybe even an orangy coral (not too pink) just for fun. I know it’s winter time currently, but if you haven’t done a blog like that already, I would love it if you did.. I think I have most of my palette pretty much figured out, but I just can’t decide on a blue. I have chosen a beautiful, soft, natural green- fernwood green. I’m looking for a blue just like that. Not too light so it’s powder blue. Not too dark and bold. Not too much green or gray. Any suggestions? What are your favorite beachy blues? Thanks, Sara

Reply
1. Post
  Author
  
  KylieMawdsley
  January 27, 2018 at 3:35 pm
  
  Hi Sara! If you’re looking for a blue that’s along the same lines as Fernwood – but blue, not green, check out BM Smoke. Now I don’t know if it will suit your home/furnishings, but it is a pretty grayed-out blue!
  ~Kylie
  
  Reply
Vicki S.
July 14, 2019 at 8:04 pm

My master bedroom is east facing with 2 windows. I’m looking for a green color that doesn’t have a lot of gray. Could you tell me if Guilford green or Prescott green would work? I’m struggling with this decision and could really use and appreciate any help you could give this old gal. I just love reading everything you’ve written about, you’re by far the most knowledgeable source for paint colors I’ve ever come across!

Reply
1. Post
  Author
  
  KylieMawdsley
  August 3, 2019 at 12:33 pm
  
  Hi Vicki! Well, it all comes down to personal preference and perception! I would say that Guilford and Prescott are GORGEOUS greens that have soft and subtle neutral backdrops, but nothing OVERLY gray. And they are both wicked gorgeous, good for say, a country or farmhouse look. Guildford is the ‘greenest’ by far, whereas Prescott is a green-blue and with your exposure, I would worry that it would feel less green for you. If you cleaned up Guilford just a wink, you’d hit something like Spring Meadow, which comes across a wink greener and shows the slightly more greige base (gray/beige) that is tucked into Guildford :).
  
  Reply
Rebecca Belanger
December 6, 2019 at 4:19 pm

Do you have any thoughts on which of the above greens pair well with each other? I have Carolina Gull in my living room and want a green for my eat-in kitchen which is adjacent. I thought maybe Sandy Hook Gray? We have Sherwin Williams’ White Duck in the other areas on the same floor. We’ve got a lot of oak furniture and stained glass shades in the kitchen and it’s just not a house that suits any sort of modern colours. I love love love the Carolina Gull with our rustic red brick fireplace and cranberry velvet drapes but it sure is a hard colour to pair with!

Reply
Leslie Ross
May 11, 2022 at 1:11 pm

Hi! In the above you show a mudroom using Avon Green, which I love! Can you share what color of white you used to paint the walls to give it the refresh you mentioned? It is absolutely beautiful and lets the green shine.

Reply
1. Post
  Author
  
  KylieMawdsley
  May 22, 2022 at 3:02 pm
  
  Oooo, I believe it was BM White Dove!
  
  Reply
Jennifer McCandless
August 30, 2023 at 4:17 pm

OOOOOOOPS!!!! ……
Do you think Dry Sage will go with honey oak orangey kitchen cabinets and natural linen?????

Reply
1. Post
  Author
  
  KylieMawdsley
  September 6, 2023 at 7:57 pm
  
  Oooo, I LIKE the sounds of this!
  
  Reply