Posted on June 14, 2023 by KylieMawdsley
SHERWIN WILLIAMS EXTRA WHITE: might not be as EXTRA white as you expect…
You shouldn’t believe EVERYTHING you read (unless you’re reading my blog) because while this color might be CALLED Extra White – it’s anything but…
I love to show RELATEABLE & REAL homes, so I ONLY use photos from my Color Consulting clients. This means I don’t always have the quality pics I need, but I have some SUPER helpful info to help you on your way!
WHAT ARE EXTRA WHITE’S UNDERTONES? IS IT WARM OR COOL?
Extra White is complicated as its undertones change depending on the type of paint you’re using. That’s right, even though Extra White’s roots suggest a very (very) vague green-yellow undertone, you might be surprised to see a) NO green whatsoever, and b) a wink of blue sometimes!
EXTRA WHITE ON WALLS
If you choose Extra White for your walls, thanks to the type of paint you’ll be using (wall paint), it will read as a cool shade of white. There’s a wink of blue in there, but you’ll hardly know it.
EXTRA WHITE ON CABINETS & TRIMS
If you paint your cabinets and trims Extra White, it will look like a slightly WARM white. This is because the base/foundation it’s mixed into (trim or cabinet paint) has yellow, whereas the wall paint base doesn’t.
Does this make it really hard to paint your walls, cabinets, and trims the same white – namely, Extra White? YOU BET IT DOES – don’t kill the messenger!
But regardless of whether you’re painting your walls, trims, or cabinets, it’s SURPRISING how darn white Extra white can look.
Why is it surprising?
As you’ll learn in the LRV section (coming up next), Extra White is not in the ‘bright and true white’ range – and it sure as heck ain’t ‘extra’ white.
HOW WHITE IS SHERWIN WILLIAMS EXTRA WHITE?
Extra White has an LRV of almost 86. This higher LRV means that while it’s in the white range, it has some depth compared to WHITER and BRIGHTER whites – making it more of a soft shade of white (technically). This might not be noticeable until you partner it with a WHITER white with an LRV of, say, 92+; then, it will look softer – maybe not off-white, but darn close. Grab a sample of Extra White and High Reflective White (LRV 93) and note the differences.
Look how great Extra White looks as a backdrop to a white toilet. Whereas some shades of white can look quite creamy-yellow compared to bath fixtures, Extra White settles in quite nicely…
If you’ve never heard about LRV, you’ll LOVE learning about this great color-picking tool – read it HERE.
USING PEEL & STICK TO SAMPLE EXTRA WHITE
SAMPLIZE offers peel-and-stick paint samples that are more AFFORDABLE, EASIER, and more ENVIRONMENTALLY FRIENDLY than traditional paint pots.
- samples arrive ON YOUR DOORSTEP in 1 DAY; depending on the location
- they’re more affordable than the sample pots/rollers/foam boards that are needed for traditional paint sampling
Get your PEEL & STICK SAMPLE OF EXTRA WHITE HERE
WHAT COLOR SHOULD MY TRIM BE IF I HAVE EXTRA WHITE WALLS?
Another version of this question would be…
If I want WHITE walls and have Extra White trim, which white should I use?
Normally, I’d suggest painting your walls and trims/cabinets the same color. However, with the variation in Extra White, you could have a whole mess of undertones on your hands, unless your paint technician is a tint-magician.
This is why I’m more likely to partner Extra White with High Reflective White. High Reflective White is pretty darn white, meaning Extra White doesn’t have dominant undertones to wrestle with.
WHITE PAINT COLORS – Walls, Cabinets & Trims, do they need to match?
The 4 Best White Paint Colors from Sherwin Williams
IS EXTRA WHITE A GOOD EXTERIOR COLOR FOR TRIM OR SIDING?
If you want a white that really just reads WHITE, Extra White could be a great fit for the trim OR the main house color!
In this next photo from one of my Color Consulting clients, Extra White is in its GLORY with cool siding (James Hardie Night Gray)
5 Tips for Choosing an Exterior Paint Color
You can expect Extra White to look WARM when your home gets good hits of sunshine (i.e., south-facing/western afternoon). In this case, ANY shade of white can pick up some yellow/cream hues.
Exterior Paint Colors: Does Exposure REALLY Matter?
WHAT WHITES ARE SIMILAR TO EXTRA WHITE
Extra White is really a shade unto itself. However, before you pick ANY white paint color, it’s important to compare it to others…
EXTRA WHITE VS. SHERWIN WILLIAMS PURE WHITE
Extra White is a touch whiter than Pure White. As for temperature, Extra White generally comes off much cooler compared to the subtle warmth in Pure White. Extra White is also CLEANER-looking than Pure White.
Cabinets in Sherwin Williams Pure White with beige tile floor
EXTRA WHITE VS. SHERWIN WILLIAMS HIGH REFLECTIVE WHITE
If you ask me, there’s no competition. High Reflective White is WHITER/brighter than Extra White (due to its higher LRV) and has virtually no undertone. This makes High Reflective White far more versatile for the average home.
Painted white surfaces in Sherwin Williams High Reflective White
EXTRA WHITE VS. BENJAMIN MOORE VS BENJAMIN MOORE SUPER WHITE
Extra White and Super White are similar as their LRVs are reasonably close – Extra White at 86, Super White at 87.36. Even so, if you compare them, Super White looks a bit brighter, a bit whiter, and has CONSIDERABLY less undertone – again, Super White wins (but of them all, High Reflective is the best for this general approach).
Cute powder room in Benjamin Moore Super White!
READ MORE
Paint Color Review of Sherwin Williams Pure White
The Ultimate Guide to Choosing White Paint Colors
Sherwin Williams 4 Best White Paint Colors
Paint Color Review of Benjamin Moore Simply White
The 8 Best Benjamin Moore White Paint Colors
Not sure which paint color is best for YOUR home?
Check out my Online Paint Color Consulting – I’d love to help!
ORIGINALLY WRITTEN IN 2019, UPDATED FOR YOU IN 2022
Share this!
Comments
Leave a Reply
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
More Posts
8 IDEAS TO MAKE YOUR LOW CEILING LOOK HIGHER
LOW CEILING IDEAS: PAINT COLORS, DECOR, & MORE Decorating or painting a room with a low ceiling can be challenging when you feel creatively stunted and short on ideas (yes,Share
Read More
The Best Ceiling Paint Colors (White & Medium & Dark): PART 2
What’s the best color to paint the ceiling? Ceilings are often referred to as the ‘fifth wall.’ However, in many cases, the ceiling doesn’t need to be treated special; itShare
Read More
Which Two White Paint Colors Go Together?
WHICH DIFFERENT SHADES OF WHITE SUIT EACH OTHER? When painting more than one surface white, such as trims, walls, and cabinets, it can be tempting to do ye ole mixShare
Read More
Hi Kylie!
Love your blog and reviews! We recently painted our kitchen cupboards SW Extra White and are trying to pick a beige/tan paint for the walls to match our 90’s venetian gold granite and stone backsplash. The rest of our home is beige and whites. Any advice would be greatly appreciated!! Thank you so much!!
Author
Hi Rhonda! That’s TOUGH. Extra White is such a cool crisp white and it’s not SUPER happy with warm beige/tan paint colours. Your best bet will be a very MUTED one that doesn’t have a strong yellow/orange/red undertone – think SW Natural Tan as a starting point.
Thank you so much Kylie!! I have learned so much from you about LRV and north vs. south facing rooms. (I wish I would have seen your blog before we had our cupboards refaced). I appreciate your help so much!!
I am having my cabinets painted tomorrow!! I am still on the fence about color. I like high reflective white the best since it shows no undertones but I’m told by my painter and paint store that it doesn’t have the coverage without the undertones. My painter says he uses “pure white” on almost all “white” cabinet jobs. Pure white seemed dingy when I am comparing samples so I got an “extra white” sample which is the same color as the trim in the kitchen and the color looks nice. You mentioned that when extra white is used on cabinets it would appear WARM. That actually what I’m hoping for to happen. Is this true with the choice of most cabinet paint?
Author
Hey Erika! It sounds like Extra White could be a good fit! As for cabinet paint, it depends if the painter uses an alkyd/oil or lacquer based paint as these can make a white look more yellow than they SHOULD (and are the bane of my existence!). I get that those paints are hardy, but they skew colors too much for me! Especially when there are so many great latex paints on the market.
How do you feel about Extra White cabinets paired with Cafe (GE line) matte white appliances? White (cabinets) on white (quartz counters and backsplash) on white (appliances) kitchen…too much white? Or is there such a thing?
I just wanted to thank you so much for all of your very helpful information. I learned of your expertise last summer when I was helping my son select paint colors for the interior of his first home. I referred so many people to your site and service over the winter and have poured over all of your articles on white paint colors for months and just placed my cabinet order for WHITE DOVE (swoon). It is a long story but I can tell you that you really saved me from making a bad decision and I appreciate it so much! Thanks for taking over when my design fatigue set in! I am sure that I will be back when I surface from this project and tackling my next! Thanks Again!
Hi Kylie,
I love your YouTube Channel! I am painting my home’s exterior with Sherwin Williams Chesterfield Gray #2849 and am considering SW Extra White for trims. What say you?
Author
Hmmmmm, I can find Westchester Gray #2849, I’m wondering if this is what you mean? If so, then YES, I think that coudl be loverly!
Recently moved into a new home, and the builder has painted all the surfaces extra white. I have ordered over 20 peel and stick samples and have been unable to locate a wall color. based on reading about extra white I am wondering if I would be better off, painting the trim, work and cabinets high reflective white in a semi gloss or satin finish. A also, my home is north facing. Thank you for your thoughts